Reply to thread

We have sailed on the DIsney Magic twice, and on Carnival Spirit, Conquest, Legend, and Fantasy.  I enjoyed all of these cruises.  My kids prefer Carnival over Disney (and they prefer RCI most of all) but my husband and I probably prefer Disney over Carnival.


The food is better on Carnival, but the service is better on Disney.  We LOVED Castaway Cay from Disney, and in our opinion no other cruseline's private island is aanywhere near as pristine and beautiful.  The Disney ships are more beautiful and elegant than the Carnival ships which are more gaudy in decor.  But Carnival gives great value for money.  We enjoy Carnival and will sail them again in the future.


Let us know what you decide.


Top