Confused about dining

C

ceejanerun

Guest
Having never cruised before, I find the whole topic of dining rather confusing! I understand you have two choices - traditional or pesonal choice dining (or whatever it's called). But I'm not sure I understand how both work fully. Does picking traditional dining mean that you eat in the same dining room every night? Does it only apply to dinner? And what are the surcharges I read about? If I pick traditional dining, does that mean I can't go somewhere else for dinner if I feel like it?

And I haven't seen much on what you can bring aboard in the way of alcohol. Is that a no-no? Are you allowed to bring on a bottle or two? How about pop?
 
C

Cruise cutie

Guest
You can hand carry in your carry on luggage wine and champagne.also soda..they do have fountain dispensed soda stickers that allow all the fountain soda you care to drink..think it;'s $22.50 for a 7 day cruise..Traditional fixed seating is 6:30 and 8:30 each night in the Dining room..there is one smoking Dining Room and One non-smoking Dining Room..we =love fixed second seating as we relax after tours and excursions,have time for a shower /nap etc..we love staying up late on ship..PC anytime dining is just that..there are different menus each night but an international menu that is aways available each night..such as Ceasar salad,Sirloin steak if you do not like the evening offerings..same as lunch..surcharges are for themed restaurants..ie:Sterling Steak House,Sante Fe.etc..booze is automatic 15% gratuity added at purchase..an additioonal corkage fee for wine brought from home to use in the Dining room..If you choose to skip a traditional seating meal..PLEASE just let the wait staff know as the WHOLE TABLE will not be served till all at that table is seated..so it's nice to be prompt for dinner or excuse yourself to the Maitre'D if Dining elsewhere..:grin..people do "smuggle on Booze"..Princess frowns on this..go with what you feel you need to do or not...Happy cruising...:daisy..Joanne
 
N

Natalia

Guest
Cruise cutie answered most of your questions, but I already had some of this typed up, so I will post it anyways:

As for your dining questions..... you are correct, there are 2 choices for dining on Princess... "Traditional" and "Personal Choice". You make your dining choice before cruising. If you prefer the traditional option, that means you must choose (prior to sailing) between two seating times, "early" seating which is at approx 6:30pm or the "late" seating which is at approx 8:15pm. You will go to dinner at whichever of those 2 times that you elect every night. You will sit at the same table (table # will appear on your cruise card). You will also choose a table size prior to cruising, from a table for 2 up to 10 or so. You will be seated with the same passengers each evening. If you opt for the PC dining, then you can go down for dinner to whichever dining room is designated for PC dining at any time within their dining hours (Im guessing between 6 and 9?? they will post the times for you). You will be seated at a different table each night, with different table mates. You may ask for any size table you wish each evening, meaning you can have a private meal for just 2 or be seated at a large table with several others. There are certainly pro's and con's to each of these numerous choices. Some prefer one, some prefer the other. Get opinions from others and see which seems to fit you best. As for breakfast and lunch, I think you used to be stuck to certain times when choosing the traditional seating option, but if I remember right, last time I was on Princess, we went to breakfast and lunch in the dining room whenever we wanted within the specified hours. There is always the buffet choice for all three meals as well. Now, for some reason if you want to eat in an alternative restauant, its suggested that you should notify your waiter ahead of time, just as a courtesy to the dining staff. They wait for the entire table to arrive before they begin serving. Also, they do go out of their way for your drinks and other preferences to make your dining experience pleasant, and it helps them to know ahead of time if you will not be there for a particular meal (speaking of dinner only here). The surchages you read about apply only to the "alternative" restaurants (does not apply to the buffet or the poolside grills), sorry I can not help you further with that as we have not tried any of them. Hope we have helped and not made it more confusing. Feel free to email me if I can help further.

Edited to add: this was already long enough but I will offer my reasons for choosing the option we do. I have tried and enjoyed the traditional seating. We made some wonderful friends which we are still in contact with many years later. It was nice to have "new friends" onboard to do things with, we even took an excursion with them later in the week. We chose the late seating so that we would never have to rush back from being in port to make our seating time. Last time we signed up for traditional seating, we ended up with tablemates from hell.... so we requested to switch to the PC dining. We didnt expect to care for it, but ended up loving it. We had no schedule to keep, ate when we wanted, and met many more people this way. We saw people we "knew" (or were at least aquainted with) at the shows, at the pools, at lunch, in port, etc. That made it kinda fun. So, its a tough choice... good luck!



Post Edited (08-02-04 17:46)
 
B

Beryl

Guest
Huh Joanne?????? All dining areas on Princess are non-smoking!!! At least they were when I last sailed and I sure hope they haven't changed!!

The Diamond and Sapphire Princess are the only 2 ships to date that have the 4 "themed" personal choice dining rooms. If you are on one of these ships you can choose from the themed menu which does not change nightly or from the traditional menu which does change each evening and is the exact same menu that is offered in the traditional dining room. The traditional dining room also offers the menu of the themed restaurants on various nights. Princess does try to make sure that everyone can experience everything available.

You can also choose to eat in one of the "premium" dining rooms. You will pay an extra surcharge for this.

If you choose traditional dining you can choose to eat in the Horizon Court or any of the Premium restaurants. You will not be turned away from the personal choice dining rooms but somehow, it doesn't seem fair to me that those who choose traditional dining feel they should be able to use the personal choice dining rooms too. There are a limited number of seats available and Personal Choice cruisers cannot use the Traditional dining room....remember, the menus are the same!!
 
C

Cruise cutie

Guest
=shrug..I DO NOT Smoke..but there were people smoking in the Dining Room..one table over..we all had a fit as they were loud,drunk and obnoxious as well as smoking.....that we were in on the Coral..so they got booted........... we were told to the Diining Room that had smoking in it...???...so thats what I typed....Glad to hear they are NON SMOKING..just going by my last cruise..sorry Beryl...=hugs...........Joanne
 
B

Beryl

Guest
I'm glad to hear that the dining room smokers got the boot. It sounds like they were inconsiderate in every possible way!
 
L

LandLockedInAZ

Guest
Quote from Beryl:

somehow, it doesn't seem fair to me that those who choose traditional dining feel they should be able to use the personal choice dining rooms too. There are a limited number of seats available and Personal Choice cruisers cannot use the Traditional dining room....


Hear, Hear!!
I chose Personal Choice on our upcoming Diamond Cruise because I wanted to enjoy the potential flexibility, but I keep hearing advice that I need to make reservations for each night as soon as we board the ship! That doesn't allow me the flexibility I desire and makes me think that the system needs to be fixed. If I wanted to know exactly where I needed to be at what time each night, I'd have chosen Traditional. :mad:
 
S

Sea-soned1

Guest
To LandLockedinAZ, I don't think you HAVE to make reservations for PC dining. You can just show up whenever, and you may have to wait a few minutes, as at any restaurant where you don't have reservations, or you may not. If you wish to eat at a particular time, and you know that ahead of time, you can make reservations. We like traditional dining, but were not able to get in when we booked a cruise late one time. We had PC assigned to us. We made reservations for a table for two each night at a certain time.........so we were able to make our own personal choice. It was right for us, but not for many others..........they just came when they wanted to.
 
B

Beryl

Guest
Hi Sea-soned1! You are of course correct that you don't have to make reservations for PC dining and my experience on the Grand Princess last year was wonderful. We did not make reservations and only had a very short wait on one evening.

The Diamond (and her sister ship the Sapphire) are a different kettle of fish however. There are 4 PC restaurants, each with it's own theme. These dining rooms are about half the size of the "regular" dining room so the number of passengers they can hold are quite limited. Passengers who have chosen PC dining are probably going to want to try each restaurant. With traditional diners also wanting to give those "themed" dining rooms a try the line ups can be very long and frustrating. Almost everything I've read from cruisers who have sailed on the Diamond Princess stress the importance of making your dinner reservations when your board.

as an aside......I was horrified to read on another board that some people actually make a reservation for 2 different times on the same evening because they are not sure what time they wish to dine but want a particular restaurant on a particular evening. If everyone did this can you imagine what it would do to the wait times?????
 
S

Sharkin

Guest
Beryl,
I got the same impression you did, that people were making multiple reservations. I too felt that this was very self centered, to put it mildly. When we sailed on the Diamond in April I got the feeling that it would be hard to make more than one reservation per day (night). It might be possible if you had traveling companions in another stateroom. You can only make reservations for dinner with the concierge, and I doubt one stateroom would be allowed to book multiple times per day (night). I don't think there would be a problem if you went to dine at a time or restaurant other than that day’s reservation, if you had a reservation. I am not sure if they ask for your stateroom when you walk in without a reservation, but I hope the do so that they may free up the reserved time for someone else.
 
S

Sea-soned1

Guest
Thanks, Beryl. Now I guess I'll just HAVE to make it a priority to book on the Diamond or Sapphire just to do a little research.........................wonder if my husband will go along with that rationale????? :)
 
B

Beryl

Guest
Sea-soned1...It sure never hurts to try :grin!!!

Sharkin...they always asked for our cabin number when we dined in the PC dining room on the Grand but they just recorded it on their form. I will be interested to see what the program is when we sail on the Diamond in February....arrrrrgh...it is so far away!!!
 
L

Lady Jag

Guest
I thought early traditional dining was at 6:15? That's what time we ate at every night in April on our Coral cruise. :? :? :? Have they changed it to 6:30?
 
Top