Hi Lynn! :wave Have you done the Southern Caribbean? I see you're already going on the Coral. Do you prefer newer ships? If you do, then the Coral would be a better choice for you. I've been reading that the ship rolls from side to side a lot. You'll have to let me know when you get back what you thought of the movement since we're considering the Coral for a cruise next March/April.
I guess my vote would be the Southern Carib. if you've never done it before. The islands are very unique and more tropical than those on the Eastern/Western Caribbean.