Jim,
Funny, I called HAL directly and told them were booked in a PH and wondered about the promotion. Though she would not tell us whether we would get a refund, she did tell me (though I am sure she wasn't supposed to) that the PH and ALL SUITES were included in that promotion, and that I should talk to my TA.
So, I guess the information wheel spins, but we never know where and how long it stops on the TRUTH!
Nevertheless I understand why BUSINESS makes these type of decisions. Promotions and discounts are marketing tools to get the maximum profit and to fill their ships. I don't think it is to their financial advantage to give everyone the BEST DEAL.
It would be nice from a consumer perspective, but not realistic. Even in our large grocery chain called Safeway, they have different prices for the same items, depending upon the city and even between different stores in the same city. It's called marketing. Frustrating, but real.
Mark
PS. Jim you got my e-mail about our 2nd sitting and table #?