Hello Ohio Edge,
From this fellow Ohioan, let me assure you, that you will be happy with the Miracle. We just returned from a cruise on her, three weeks ago. That was our second time on the Miracle. So far I have to say she's tied with the Legend as our favorite Carnival ship.
We've cruised on the Victory twice and on the Triumph, also. We much preferred the Spirit class ships (Miracle and Legend) . Better deck plan overall, and nicer decor for sure. Definitely easier to navigate, as the others have said. The service level on the ship seems to be climbing. It was pretty good last time, but I was impressed with the smiles on the staff, and the helpfulness, which seem a notch better now. The ship itself looks in top shape. And we really enjoyed the new cruise director Malcolm. He was a big improvement over the gal they had last year when we first sailed on the Miracle.
As for the food, it was very good, but hubby and I had some bad luck with the beef selections on the dinner menu, not being as tender as we would expect. We avoided them after a few tries. The entertainment was excellent, although a disappointment for us as most big shows were repeats. The comic was new though and really funny. Don't miss him.