musicmom, I wish I could help but about the only thing I can say is: we cruised theold Star (not the Star of today) when it was part of NCL. It was the original Texaribbean cruise. Many had major problems and we were nervous, but the price was right. In fact so right that our kids gave it to us for a 40th anniversary present. Needless to say we were thrilled. As it turned out the ship had no problems, the cabins were nice sized complete with bath tubs and the observation lounge the nicest I have ever seen. Was it the cruise from Heaven, No, but not the one from Hell either. I think the kids program gets a bum wrap sometimes. There are those who want the kids baby sat 24/7 and that isn't what a family vacation is all about in my estimation. There should be things for the kids to do away from mom and dad, but most of the time the family would want to be together I would think. If you go with the attitude "this is not the Dawn" but a whole new experience you should be just fine. If you read about my favorite ships you will see: one is the Sun, with class and almost Glitz, the other the Sea, with nothing like that, but its own nitch. Have a great time, and lets hope the weather co-operates!
NMNita