Hi, Yana - we sailed on the Carnival Legend for our honeymoon in Nov '02 - absolutely wonderful - the food was the best we've ever had on a ship and we've been on 4 NCL, 2 Celebrity, and 2 Carnival. Of the 8 ships - this was by far our favorite! We just did the Norwegian Dawn in April '03, and while the artwork is fantastic & it's a very pretty ship, there were a number of little things that I didn't like as well -
1) the corridors by the cabins are much narrower on NCL
2) food is good on NCL, but not as good or as much variety as Carnival (for the buffet and restaurant meals), and we preferred the Legend's Golden Fleece supper club to the restaurants on the Dawn
3) the items in the gift shops were very limited in selection on NCL - we collect ship models, refrigerator magnets & Christmas ornaments of the ships - NCL didn't have any of these things and didn't have any plans to get any (very tiny ship souvenir selection, except for t-shirts)
4) we always (until now) have bought the embarkation photo, but NCL would only sell it as a part of a much more expensive package, with keychain and wallet size photos, which we (and most of the other passengers) didn't want. NCL did not get any money from us in the photo area
5) embarkation was very slow & disorganized with NCL, even if you were a Latitudes member
on the other hand, NCL had a much better coffee shop on board, which I preferred for my morning tea & Irish coffee over Carnival
Entertainment was about the same, although the NCL Dawn wins out with The Liar's Club late night comedy show.
Hope this helps!
Jane-Atlanta
Post Edited (06-26-03 12:20)