Reply to thread

I've been on both (actually, sister ships of Imagination and Majesty) and offer this comparison:


Staterooms:  Carnival (Royal's are MUCH smaller!)

Housekeeping: Carnival

Food Quality: Royal

Food Qualtity: Royal

Dining Room Service: Royal

Bar/Lounge Service: Royal

Fun atmosphere: Carnival

Romantic  atmosphere: Royal (can't beat their Viking Crown lounge!)

Spa/Health Club: Carnival

Casino: Carnival

Friendliness of staff: Royal

Kids program: Carnival

Nightly entertainment: Royal



That said, I don't believe that Royal is stuffy at all. you'll have a blast on both.  So, its up to you. Good luck on the proposal!


Top