Royal Caribbean beats Carnival, hands down, especially for her age group...
We've cruised on seven different cruise lines over the years, most with our two daughters as they grew up from the ages of 3 and 5 on...(they're now 23 and 25)...Their favorite line, by far, is Royal Caribbean...My older daughter, Heather, went on her first cruise without us last year--her and her old college roomie--They chose the Royal Caribbean Freedom of the Seas. For one week, they surfed, they rock climbed, they ice skated, they sang Karaoke...they had the time of their lives.
Heather's been on several Royal Caribbean cruises...and a few Carnivals as well...
She doesn't like Carnival...finds them tacky...Doesn't think they offer a lot to do except to just "hang out"...she by far prefers Royal Caribbean for all the stuff they have geared toward younger people...
The younger sister agrees...
We'll be on Mariner of the Seas in two weeks and she's upset we're not taking her (she just graduated college and is working her first job and doesn't get any vacation time yet)...