Our 8 year old was happy as clam with the Kids Crew. The kids don't care what the room looks like and the counselors were great! No counselors were under 18, I assure you. They all took a real interest in my kids - and the kids loved doing things in the stairwell foyers (they are actually more like living rooms than foyers - so don't be discouraged by that either-you'll find families all over the boat playing games, reading, and planning excursion on the furnishings in these areas - just another public room furnished well with plenty of floor space!!) and roaming around the boat singing songs!! Our daughter couldn't have been happier!! I loved that they arranged for time with the families because otherwise the I'd never have seen her!! You can arrange babysitting if you want, but we didn't. Our daughter made friends she's still in touch with online and they still love all the little nicknames the counselors have;( ie, YoYo) My older kids didn't have anyone in their group - some kids just don't sign up. But they didn't mind - they got a counselor (April) all to themselves!! They could change things at the drop of hat - and did, often! She was great with them - and seemed VERY happy with her job. I was very pleased with the program, as saw that security was a big issue with the crew - ID bracelets, etc. (our oldest son couldn't even check out his sister, it had to be one of us, but that was probably best).
Lori