We went with Cat-H on deck 2, small porthole, I'ma bit claustrophobic, so this suited me fine, I don't care how big the porthole was just as long as I could peek outside! The last cruise we were on we had a Balconey, but since this is just a 4-day I'd much rather settle for the porthole and have extra $$$$ to spend in Nassau! Your very lucky to live in Florida, I use to live in Tampa, now reside in Georgia, we love to leave out of Port Canaveral as it's only an 8-hour drive for us, leaving out of Miami it's a 12-hour drive!