we've been twice. first time rented a 4x4 right as you leave the terminal and head right... toured the island with new cruising friends... saw the natural bridge... while it was still there... the mines... the natural forest... got lost, found our way.... hit the light house, then a few beaches on the way back.... palm, eagle, divi.
second time... no 4x4, rented a minivan-bad choice... flat with in 15 minutes of "off road for us", regular road for the locals... the spare was flat.... CHECK the SPARE!!!!! this took 2 hours plus to fix, but we still toured, skipped the hills and off road and hit a beach, ate at the italian restaurant on the hill with the lighthouse, great sights, excellent service, high prices like at home, still worth it. daughter and grandma shopped, loved it... carlos and charlies here was lame, IMHO