Are they going to start allowing platinum members into the CL now if they aren't already packed with d and d+? Or maybe they will cut the diamonds out of the CL if they have too many d+ on board. They have their perks for C&A levels. They should stick with them or at least not give them extras that they don't yet qualify for.
GS+ pax use the CL anyways.
I think paid (not upgraded) OS and RS pax should receive 3 cruise credits on a normal 7-nighter to justify the price paid.
Also, credits on those cheap 3, 4 night cruises on the Majesty, Sovereign, Monarch should be cut to 0.5.
There's definitely difference between achieving D+ sailing 12 pricey European cruises in a RS/OS/GS (10-20 thousand dollars
each) Versus 12 Bahamas cruises in a JS (one thousand dollars max), and I think RCI should recognize that, and reward its passengers accordingly.